Avenged Sevenfold “City of Evil” Album Review
February 3, 2012 in Album RealViews, Music
01. Beast and the Harlot Hot damn – and I mean damn — could an opening track be any more perfect? Every pound of the double bass drums, the Zeus- lightning-quick guitaring, and the dominating vocals of Shadows all create such a relentless, bulldozer of a track. “Beast and the Harlot” is a stone-cold stunner and an absolute kick-ass number to kick off City of Evil.The way the guitars erupt in the intro over Shadows’ falsetto-like scream will send chills down your spine and adrenaline to your neck because yeah, you’re going to want to headbang like a veteran porn star giving a blowjob. The verses are fast and full of testosterone while the choruses get in touch with A7X’s melodic side, showcasing an improvement in song writing right off the bat (especially the key change in the last chorus). The drum solo and the absolutely blazing guitar solo is top notch and calling them “impressive” would be a disservice. “Beast and the Harlot” is as perfect as melodic metal can possibly get and it’s up for debate as to whether it’s the best song on the album — that should say enough about the quality of this album.
Grade: 100
02. Burn It Down To be fair, I’m not sure how you’re supposed to follow up “Beast and the Harlot”, but “Burn It Down” unfortunately goes down the forgettable route. It starts off great but it sputters out past the halfway mark. The screeching guitars and hectic drum rolls that bleed into the melodic, upbeat guitar harmonies in the intro are great. The verses are aggressive enough and the choruses are greatly layered and built up to perfectly. Shadows’ voice might grate on your ears during the bridge, depending on your tolerance for his not-so-great vocal moments, as he can get nasally quite frequently. “Burn It Down” is an okay song with some decent moments scattered throughout, but I just don’t see myself coming back to it too often.
Grade: 55
03. Blinded In Chains Much like the prior track, “Blinded In Chains” opens up with snare rolls and harmonic guitars but in a much, much more effective manner. The verses are dark and aggressive and the double-pedaling is a great addition to the second half of the verses. The chorus is brief and great in its delivery and build up. Every instrument tears it up, having moments to shine and all culminating to one hell of an outro that sees the song having a complete tonal shift and for the better. The atmosphere and dark mood bolster the fantastic outro, with its intricate drumming, perfectly strummed guitars, and Shadows’ eerie vocalizations. It’s worth sitting through the rest of “Blinded In Chains” (not like that’s a bad thing anyways) just for the jaw-dropping ending that comes out of nowhere that will have you on a testosterone high.
Grade: 88
04. Bat Country Ah, another home run from the boys! As you’ve noticed by now, Shadows has significantly decreased the use of his screams (a creative decision, not because of surgery as many are lead to believe) and it’s nice to hear it every now and then, no matter its brevity. The verses, thanks to the tremolo picking of Gates and Vengeance, move along at a fantastically brisk pace while the chorus switches things up, going for a more melodic structure rather than plowing through like in the verses. An eye-widening guitar solo is unleashed after the first chorus, showing the A7X men know how to keep their song structures mostly unpredictable. To add another layer to their lead single is a slowed down, incredibly catchy and hypnotic post-chorus section — a great addition.
Grade: 94
05. Trashed and Scattered This is a weird song to review because it has all the elements of a bloody good metal song I love, but the elements just don’t quite reach the “greater than the sum of their parts” status. The verses are lightning-quick with the guitarists shredding up a storm throughout and the choruses slows things down a tad with some rolling, toe-tapping bass. The Rev is absolutely clinical in his drumming aggression and cymbal finesse, making the track a much stronger one. Shadows’ hits some great, raspy high notes near the end. Maybe if the song was tighter and less meaty, it’d be better, but it’ll have to settle for just “good”.
Grade : 75

06. Seize the Day The first slow (and only) ballad of the album, you can leave it to the boys to make sure their chest-thumping bravado can still be felt in a softer song. Acoustic guitars lead the way over Shadows’ most soothing vocal performance on the album. The verses and chorus are extremely melodic, making it a fun song to sing along to. The raw emotion of possibly not seeing your significant half is greatly bolstered in the second chorus, bridge, and outro as The Rev (who sings the hair-raising high background vocals) and Shadows hit some chills-inducing notes that leave a lasting impression. The guitar solo is more on the simple side but with A7X, that’s not a bad thing because Gates works his magic in the melodic solo that amplifies the song, as does the beat change-up during the solo. This is one of City of Evil’s greatest songs and an A7X classic.
Grade: 96
07. Sidewinder Gates’ lead guitar over the chugs of Zacky combine to make a formidable intro and verses. The chorus is a good slowing of pace with The Rev playing around with cymbals. The number starts to lose some steam around the bridge but it’s a brief moments as, once again, The Rev’s cymbal play saves the day. The unquestionable standout of “Sidewinder” is, hands down, the Spanish-influenced acoustic outro segment that comes out of nowhere and hot damn doe it sound sexy. Gates and his father team up for a knockout of a blistering acoustic solo over another acoustic guitar. Shadows’ vocals sound great throughout the lengthy outro as does The Rev’s great adaptive drumming and congo play. It’s the best ending segment of any song on the album. Don’t let their tattooed punk-boy imagery fool you, these guys have a passion for music as it clearly, clearly shows in this beautiful segment.
Grade: 93
08. The Wicked End Christ finally gets a solo moment in the beginning over the eerie guitars of Gates and Vengeance. The verses are just as fast as any other song on here and when it comes to the chorus, the midtempo change-up is great as Shadows perfectly leads the way into it with his perfectly raspy delivery. Remember when I said the guys are music aficionados? Well, they show it again with the haunting and absolutely epic orchestral and choir bridge that comes after the sweeping guitar solo. It’s a quiet build-up that slowly erupts into Shadows hitting some of the highest notes he’s ever hit, creating this boner-inducing hell of a time. Gates has a brief solo after and the following verse after is a brutal affair. It’s incredible how diverse this album is and how many colors of music they’re willing to blend, hitting one home run after another.
Grade: 92
09. Strength of the World The intro is no doubt inspired by old school Western sensibilities with the plucked acoustic guitar providing the foundation for the beautiful orchestra segment before Gates and the boys come rocking in. While not as strong as the two prior tracks, it’s still another showcase for Avenged Sevenfold’s diversity and willingness to change things up, never settling for monotony. The differentiating factor here is the great blend of the cheesy (but in a good way) melodic guitar solo over the swelling symphony. The verses have the signature chugs and the chorus is good enough, adding in gang vocals to shout “strength of the world!” as Shadows sings a somewhat catchy melody over them.
Grade: 85
10. Betrayed Well, shit, guess it was too good to last, huh? “Betrayed” is easily the weakest song on the album and, in many ways, it’s pretty terrible. When held against the great songs on City of Evil, it just comes off as lazy and safe. I know the message is about the murder of a metal legend, but you would think that would motivate them to make it a greater track, right? The verses are decent but the hook comes off as incredibly mediocre. The only actual good part for me was a small segment where the guitars overlap each other in a pleasant way over The Rev’s hi-hats. While the actual musicianship isn’t terrible, it’s the way they don’t add up that sticks with you (not to mention it’s unnecessary length of six minutes), making for a boring and forgettable listen.
Grade: 50
11. M.I.A. This is it, the album closer! Shadows’ sleepy voice over the softly plucked guitar lead the song off before Shadows shows off his vocal might during the first verse. His voice can be spotty, sounding great in some parts and iffy in others but one thing’s for sure, it’s a unique voice. Gates’ solo is dizzying over The Rev’s horse-gallop-double-pedal pattern, showing us why he’s one of this generations truly greatest. The chorus is forgettable and if it weren’t for Shadows’ vocals, they’d be even more so. “M.I.A.” isn’t as strong as most of the other songs on here, but as a closer, it’s decent enough to get the job done.
Grade: 74
City of Evil is easily one of the best rock albums released since the turn of the century. There are an absurd amount of jaw-dropping, head-fucking-banging moments of pure testosterone-injected musicianship. Gates truly, truly stuns with his thunderous sweep picks and blistering solos as does The Rev with his absolutely earth-shattering drumming. His rolls, cymbal finesse, and knack for always changing things up assures that each song will be a treat for drummers. Shadows’ vocals are hit or miss, but thankfully it’s a lot more hit than miss here. A lot of A7X fans might dread the fact he ditched the screaming, but I for one was never all that impressed by his screams and much prefer his raspy vocals and occasional screams. City of Evil is a crowning achievement of metal musicianship, bringing a remarkably impressive diverse and eclectic listen. If you are at all interested in hearing how great metal musicians operate at their finest, look absolutely no further than City of Evil.
Report Card
Instruments: 100
Production: 88
Lyrics: 88
Vocals: 88
Overall
96








It’s well-known now that hall-of-fame drummer, Jimmy “The Rev” Sullivan, has passed away. His incredible speed, technique, and respectable vocals all blended into a triple-threat (I’m not even counting the man’s incredibly creative songwriting) that demanded the attention of the head-banger’s nation. ‘So Far Away’, like many of the songs off of their album “Nightmare”, is dedicated to the The Rev. It’s because of this real-world tragedy that ‘So Far Away’ resonates so strongly on an emotional level.
RealTalk