The Weeknd “Echoes of Silence” Mixtape Review
January 18, 2012 in Album RealViews, Music

1.D.D The Canadian-native lead singer of The Weeknd, Abel Tesfaye, known for his sensual and unique voice, beginning with a cover of Michael Jackson’s “Dirty Diana”. It can be said that most Michael Jackson songs covered or sampled are painful but in this case he intensifies the song with what seems to be only his voice, drums and a synthesizer. The song is edgy and bold and hard not to sing along to passionately. This is easily the best song on the entire tape. It’s extremely memorable with it’s unique dark twist and is a perfect opener.
Grade: 93
02.Montreal This track opens with Tesfaye speaking in french to the soft notes of a piano. The first thirty seconds of the track lead you to believe some amazing musical number is about to follow, however, the song falls short of interesting due to a standard, three-note pattern beat and cliché background singers. The lyrics aren’t memorable and there’s hardly a change from verse to chorus. The song would have stood out if he actually broke the pattern, but it ends up quickly becoming reminiscent of a church hymn.
Grade: 65
03.Outside It’s extremely frustrating to listen to this song because, like the others, it entices you with with a bizarre but unforgettable beat but the singing is so drab. All the songs have almost the same beat, lyrics, and atmospheres. The song has so much potential but its overly strong focus on the beat robs it of said potential. “Outside” may be better off as an instrumental and have a million more uses because one of them is not “good song”. It isn’t like the lyrics are bad and are actually heavy, it’s just the delivery makes them come off as insincere.
Grade: 53
04.XO/ The Host Finally things pick back up if you managed to stay awake to the fourth song. The trippy beat and electric guitar make this song. It sounds like an R&B cover of what could be an awesome Jimi Hendrix song but with a drunken twist since the lyrics are a recollection of any party-goers night, stressing drugs, alcohol, sex, and remorse; I guess it’s the 70′s in a short story. Just when you think about changing the song, a xylophone interrupts the song, giving the beat a colorful range of tones, making the song more varied but drowning out the singer. When you think the track is over, “The Host” comes on and it turns out it’s a completely necessary outro.
Grade: 80
05.Initiation When I first listened to this track I honestly thought my stereo was broken or I was unknowingly drugged because strange does not even begin to describe “Initiation”. In an attempt to be unique, Tesfaye tweaked his voice to different speeds, making his voice sound unnaturally high or deep. I’m not sure what he was going for but I personally felt like I was being serenaded by Sloth from 1985 classic, The Goonies and a creepy chipmunk. This makes it hard to hear the lyrics or focus on anything else so it’s a complete waste of four minutes. Also, why is this song four minutes?
Grade: 25
06.Same Old Song The irony of this song title kills me. I shouldn’t even have to say it but this song has no characteristics to distinguish itself, which is sad because Tesfaye has such a unique voice that has so much potential. I suppose the goal of the track was to be mellow and for those bedroom activities but the only thing you’ll manage to focus on is wishing this song would end. If you can memorize the song after listening to it twice, it isn’t always a good thing. Sad.
Grade: 67
07.The Fall This track is five minutes of Tesfaye telling the world a story about I don’t even know what because he tells it in chant form. The beat doesn’t actually drop until the middle and his voice is hard to hear over the obnoxiously simple but loud drum. The most disappointing part is the build-up is like some epic musical bang set to blow your mind but he can’t seem to get out of the box and capitalize on the build. Simply using unique instruments won’t make the song suddenly interesting.
Grade: 48
08.Next Somehow things pick back up at this point with a resonant piano riff and an erratic beat to accompany it. The lyrics are catchy, make sense, and are personable. Rather than droning on about alcohol and night lights, Tesfaye breaks down and shows some emotion other than apathy. Unfortunately, I think the only thing that makes this song good is that it’s unlike the other songs on the tape but it’s still really not all that great.
Grade: 75
09. Echoes of Silence This being the closing track of the mix-tape, I’d expect something that would leave a positive impression on me to help disregard the rest of the album…it’s an average slow song that falls short. The song is four notes on a piano with five notes singing along about lost love but he could honestly be singing about gardening and you wouldn’t notice because the words slur together. It’s not terrible, but it’s not good either. This would have made a better opening track but the mix-tape as a whole would have been better off as an instrumental and played in a strip club. This being only their third mix-tape, they’ve got a lot more to develop on.
Grade: 83
Report Card
Instruments: 87
Production: 68
Lyrics: 74
Vocals: 50
Overall
74

































RealTalk